Feelings vs. Physics: What Matters Most for Electric Guitar Tone?

I already spoiled the answer in the last part by saying that it’s not the most important factor, and that the correct question to ask is, “How much of what is audible in the unplugged, or primary, sound will be present in the amplified tone?” To be clear, I didn’t say that the wood has no influence on the electrified tone, and that all electric guitars sound the same. To cut to the chase, here is my formula on this, based on proven physics as well as several decades of expertise: The more solidly an electric guitar is built, the less influence its structure has on the amplified tone. We can invert this thinking, too: The more an electric guitar has the qualities of an acoustic guitar, the greater the influence its primary structure will have through an amp.

This is not my original wisdom, but is based on decades of intensive scientific research by Professor Manfred Zollner from the German Regensburg University, which mostly matches my experiences from many years in the business. Professor Zollner developed this headnote approximately 15 years ago, and in my opinion, it’s the closest thing to the truth. His actual theory is that the wooden structure of an electric guitar has close to zero influence on the electrified tone.

Let’s form a few groups according to different construction methods, which can give us some basic guidelines.